French liberal intellectuals, politicians, and military officers recognized that Bugeaud’s tactics seemed to conflict with human rights norms. Nevertheless, the French legitimated these tactics by invoking a specific principle; namely that “the end justifies the means.”“We have found a more efficient way than burning crops: waging an incessant war which impacts the population through individuals and in all their interests. The flights, the continuous alarms, the enormous losses inflicted by the razzias and even by mere relocations, the women and children we captured; the old, the women, the children and the herds who perished from fatigue and hunger; the necessity to live the entire winter in the harshest mountains, on summits covered with snow – that is what for better or worse pushed the Arabs into submission.”[9]
One of the most infamous figures involved in Bugeaud’s conquest of Algeria was lieutenant colonel Lucien-François de Montagnac (1803-1845), who partook in numerous massacres. Montagnac justifies his behavior based on the principle that the end justifies the means. Hence, writing in 1843, he states:“These murmurs would seem to tell me that the [Parliament] Chamber find this means [of waging war] too barbarous. Gentlemen, one does not make war with philanthropic sentiments. When one wants the end, one must want the means, when there are no other [means] than those I have indicated, it is necessary to employ them.”[10]
Elsewhere Montagnac adds,“He who wants the end wants the means. In my opinion, all populations [of Algeria] who do not accept our conditions must be razed, everything must be taken, ransacked, regardless of age or sex; the grass should no longer grow where the French army set foot.”[11]
Notably, Bugeaud’s general tactics were endorsed by Alexis de Tocqueville (1805 – 1859). Tocqueville is one of the most famous liberal intellectuals in history. He was a member of France’s parliament, and was its foremost expert on Algeria. Tocqueville played a central role in directing French policy in Algeria.“Behold, my good friend, how it is necessary to make war on the Arabs: kill all men till the age of fifteen, take all the women and children, put them on boats, and sent them to the Marquesas Islands or elsewhere; in a word, annihilate all who will not crawl at our feet like dogs.”[12]
Writing in 1846, Tocqueville states:“I have often heard men in France who I respect, but whom I do not approve, find it wrong that we burn harvests, that we empty silos, and finally that we seize unarmed men, women, and children. These are, according to me, unfortunate necessities, but ones to which may people who wants to make war on Arabs is obliged to submit. And, if it is necessary to speak my thoughts, these acts do not cause me more revulsion nor even as much revulsion as many others that the law of war obviously authorizes and which take place in all the wars of Europe…I believe that the law of war authorizes us to ravage the country and that we must do that either by destroying the harvests at harvesting time or at all times by making these rapid incursions that one calls razzias and whose object is to seize men or herds.”[13]
The French conquest of Algeria offers some important lessons.“Once we have condoned the great violence that is conquest, I believe that we must not shrink from the smaller violences which are absolutely necessary to consolidate it.”[14]