Do We Need SFG Constitution Reform On 2 State Rule?

[GaradShabeel]

FGS created the MAP and sent it to the world bank. World bank can be taken to bosaso to galkacyo on a drive and its 750 KM, all that land is ours. Same distance as Mogadishu to Hamar. What's a silly map going to change except give PL ammo to add more 'falsehoods' of hawiye to the world so they can be descredited or taken with suspicion anything they say on politics also.

Why did FGS create such a map then? It basically goes against the very same constitution that the gov't is built upon and supposed to follow, lol.

 

[Dalalos_ibn_Adali]

I think it's more to do with the conflicts of 'territorial disputes' by GM, which is why SSC is also disputed as SL also claimed it.

But the constitution doesn't given N. Mudug to GM, which is what I was trying to imply. Also, that map comes from the World Bank and not FGS.

Are you crazy FGS is more in favour of all of Mudug being part of GM than the IC, its the IC that designated North Mudug disputed territory after PL got out played by HSM they complained to the IC.

This happened during HSM previous term and nothing has changed since then.

 

[DR OSMAN]

Why did FGS create such a map then? It basically goes against the very same constitution that the gov't is built upon and supposed to follow, lol.

Let them do it becuz PL can list all the lies they do, it helps us indirectly bro if ur politician. U can show the world look they lied on this and take them for a tour, and then tell the world, imagine what else they lie about, which will make westerner 'condemn' hawiye in politics also. Hawiye worst enemy is hawiye, they operate in a world with hawiye minds.

 

[GaradShabeel]

Are you crazy FGS is more in favour of all of Mudug being part of GM than the IC, its the IC that designated North Mudug disputed territory after PL got out played by HSM they complained to the IC.

This happened during HSM previous term and nothing has changed since then.

Yes, I acknowledged the bolded part. But in my previous post, I separated the FGS from the constitution, even though I shouldn't, as they oftentimes violate it to make it suit their objectives.

 

[canjeeroiyoshah]

View attachment 290764

They should rearrange the original provinces by incorporating Cayn into Sool, and Caynabo should be added to Togdheer. Sanaag can be split in half.

North Mudug can go with Nugaal or become their own province. I don't know why there's an insistence on keeping the original provinces. If peace is the goal, then we should do whatever it takes. This is not the South, where there's a lot more diversity and applying this sort of thing might not be as clear-cut.

 

[Chaseyourdreamzz]

They should rearrange the original provinces by incorporating Cayn into Sool, and Caynabo should be added to Togdheer. Sanaag can be split in half.

North Mudug can go with Nugaal or become their own province. I don't know why there's an insistence on keeping the original provinces. If peace is the goal, then we should do whatever it takes. This is not the South, where there's a lot more diversity and applying this sort of thing might not be as clear-cut.

North mudug can definitely become its own province the population is there land is big as well

 

[Dalalos_ibn_Adali]

They should rearrange the original provinces by incorporating Cayn into Sool, and Caynabo should be added to Togdheer. Sanaag can be split in half.

North Mudug can go with Nugaal or become their own province. I don't know why there's an insistence on keeping the original provinces. If peace is the goal, then we should do whatever it takes. This is not the South, where there's a lot more diversity and applying this sort of thing might not be as clear-cut.

creating new districts and provinces could lead to more violence lol. I do however agree that the administrative lines are old and outdated.

 

[The Midlands]

Dadka Reer SSC-khatumo laguma cabsiinkaro Narrative ka ah,2 Gobol Iyo badh. Waa in la ogaadaa Dastuurka somalia in uu yahay Qabyo qoraal aan Wali Somali kuheshiin.Maamulka SSC-khaatumo wa Maamul buuxa oo Katirasan DFS

Xilibaan Macow

Is it time as Somalis take out the 2 state rule for state formation? it doesn't make any sense. A state like Bari/Sanaag territorially is worth 6 states in the South. I mean Hobyo no disrespect to Nugaal, is the same size as Nugaal territory wise. I mean middle Juba is the same size as 'ceel-dheer' a district in GM.

This dilemma can be solved by setting minimum 'territory sq measurements' due to the un-reliablity of the 18 state model as that is the only 'accurate' thing we have to work with.

By the way Darawish were the founders of Somalinimo, I doubt any constitution will be settled without their input.

What about Sanaag Galbeed, Isaaq Ceynabo district of Sool? Should they claim the whole sanaag on paper like the case of Galmudug that claims the whole mudug theoretically or in the map under Farmaajo Govt?
I would like to split North west of Jowhar from Middle Shabelle and add it to Hiiraan State its only XL and Gaaljecel areas.

 

[The Midlands]

Are you crazy FGS is more in favour of all of Mudug being part of GM than the IC, its the IC that designated North Mudug disputed territory after PL got out played by HSM they complained to the IC.

This happened during HSM previous term and nothing has changed since then.

Exactly otherwise Galmudug will be illegitimate. then UN envoy said the Northern Mudug will be administered by PL not Galmudug. This is the FMS map under Farmaajo.