Banaadir and Muqdisho will seperate in the near future

Do you agree that Banaadir 4 million strong should be allowed to vote in their representatives?

  • Yes

    Votes: 15 88.2%
  • No I think the guy in villa somalia should decide for 4 million people from the mayor down

    Votes: 3 17.6%

  • Total voters
    17

Jungle

VIP
Somali constitution chapter 1
Article 9. The Capital City of the Nation
The status of the capital city of Somalia shall be determined in the constitutional review process, and
the two houses of the Somali Federal Parliament shall enact a special law with regards to this issue.

Banaadir and Muqdisho will be seperate in the future. Mucaarad and muxaafid of banaadir agree reer banaadir must vote in their representatives. 1 mayor Thabit got thrown out because of his guddi and yariisow aun possibly lost his life because of speaking on it and his opposition to a 4.5 sharing system of banaadir which was suggested by villa somalia.

He seperated banadir and muqdisho inti fahmeso

This was an ongoing talking point before the election issue came up and it wil come up in parliament within the first year of the next presidents term im sure. All the bitter hiraab candidates and there will be many will stick their funds into this hopefully to get it past parliament. We are strong advocates obviously and so are hg





The federal government can be given maybe 4 or so districts with the port and aden cade. banaadir gets 16. Its gives anyone the chance of being president imo.
 

TekNiKo

“I am an empathic and emotionally-aware person.
VIP
This is a great idea but how will police work? Will FGS have seperate police? Benadir Police force? It would be a bit confusing right? Anyways if every degmo had 100 soldiers patrolling day and night that actually live in that degmo there would be no AS left.
 

Jungle

VIP
This is a great idea but how will police work? Will FGS have seperate police? Benadir Police force? It would be a bit confusing right? Anyways if every degmo had 100 soldiers patrolling day and night that actually live in that degmo there would be no AS left.
It wouldnt be confusing at all if clear borders were set between whats to be called muqdisho and whats to be called Banaadir State
 

Periplus

SYL supporter
VIP
Generally in federalism, the entire city becomes a federal territory.

If you make some districts federal territory and others part of a FMS, you complicate things logistically and legally.

The sacrifice of being a capital city in a federal country is not becoming a state. Ask Washington DC, Addis Ababa, Canberra, New Delhi, Kuala Lumpur etc.
 

Reverse

booliska federal 🚓
This is a great idea but how will police work? Will FGS have seperate police? Benadir Police force? It would be a bit confusing right? Anyways if every degmo had 100 soldiers patrolling day and night that actually live in that degmo there would be no AS left.
Similar to the U.S there is DHS/Federal Protective Service, which is the law enforcement agency servicing federal property in D.C and across the U.S. Then there's D.C Metro Police which handles everything not handled by FPS/Secret Service/U.S Capitol Police off of federal property.

Somalia needs to also establish a federal police force that's sole duty is to protect federal landmarks, federal prisons, federal court houses, & more only on land owned by the government across the country.

Each state security force would handle security of airports, ports, state prisons, highways, criminal investigations, etc

Each city police force handles local policing, public safety, etc.

The federal government would also fund each state to set up a police network for inter-state police cooperation outside of federal control.

This would drastically optimize security and operations across the country. Also not to mention, would have great accountability so that things can't be shoved under the rug with clear and concise rank structure.

Banaadir is going in the right direction. The political capital of any country should never be the economic/financial or even the entertainment capital in which Mogadishu is all three.
 

Periplus

SYL supporter
VIP
Somalia needs to also establish a federal police force that's sole duty is to protect federal landmarks, federal prisons, federal court houses, & more only on land owned by the government across the country.

Completely agree with this.

In recent years, the FMS and FGS have been selling or gifting government land to the highest bidder.

All the public parks in Xamar are now sold and even the former military base in Galkacyo was sold by PL to Amal Express.
 
Somali constitution chapter 1


Banaadir and Muqdisho will be seperate in the future. Mucaarad and muxaafid of banaadir agree reer banaadir must vote in their representatives. 1 mayor Thabit got thrown out because of his guddi and yariisow aun possibly lost his life because of speaking on it and his opposition to a 4.5 sharing system of banaadir which was suggested by villa somalia.

He seperated banadir and muqdisho inti fahmeso

This was an ongoing talking point before the election issue came up and it wil come up in parliament within the first year of the next presidents term im sure. All the bitter hiraab candidates and there will be many will stick their funds into this hopefully to get it past parliament. We are strong advocates obviously and so are hg





The federal government can be given maybe 4 or so districts with the port and aden cade. banaadir gets 16. Its gives anyone the chance of being president imo.
It has nothing to to with us HG, it is an abgaal city lets remember that.
 
Banaadir territory has to be expanded and Merca city should become part of the new state and I also believe old Xamar districts be part of it while govt areas are exempt from the state authority
 
I'm against the separation of Banaadir and Muqdisho. According to the constitution the FGS cant directly control any region. The FGS are representing the whole country, all they need are buildings to operate from.

Banaadir should be its own state while housing the premises of the FGS. Just like in Berlin.
:samwelcome:
Screenshot_20211001-212105_Chrome.jpg
 
I have an Idea.
Lets break up banaadir into two. South banaadir and shabellada hoose can become a state. waqooyiga banaadir and shabelada dhexe can become another state. Then the idea of hiraan state could become a reality.


4 states and counting.
 

Trending

Top