B haplogroup in Somalia?

Status
Not open for further replies.

T1a

Oberbefehlshaber der Somalier Genetik Gruppe
upload_2018-12-18_13-12-45.png


Show yourselves:hemad:
 

Attachments

  • upload_2018-12-18_13-12-29.png
    upload_2018-12-18_13-12-29.png
    31.6 KB · Views: 195

Apollo

Staff Member
Aren’t Haplogroups A and B Hunter gatherer and Nilote markers respectively?

It doesn't exist natively in ethnic Somalis. Somalis can only have E-M35, T-L208, and J1. Nilotes and HG's have different A/B versions from Bantus splitting off tens of thousands of years.

The B versions found in Somalia are the Bantu sub-types matching SEA Bantus within a few hundred years (not ancient). Bantus are not just E-M2, they also have E-M98 & B-M182 sub-clades.

All those Arabs you see in that list have Swahili/SEA versions as well: slave trade.
 
since your name is T1a can you clarify if haplogroup T is cushitic or semitic?

It doesn't exist natively in ethnic Somalis. Somalis can only have E-M35, T-L208, and J1. Nilotes and HG's have different A/B versions from Bantus splitting off tens of thousands of years.

The B versions found in Somalia are the Bantu sub-types matching SEA Bantus within a few hundred years (not ancient). Bantus are not just E-M2, they also have E-M98 & B-M182 sub-clades.

All those Arabs you see in that list have Swahili/SEA versions as well: slave trade.
what about Somalis with T-M184? are we not ethnic

It doesn't exist natively in ethnic Somalis. Somalis can only have E-M35, T-L208, and J1. Nilotes and HG's have different A/B versions from Bantus splitting off tens of thousands of years.

The B versions found in Somalia are the Bantu sub-types matching SEA Bantus within a few hundred years (not ancient). Bantus are not just E-M2, they also have E-M98 & B-M182 sub-clades.

All those Arabs you see in that list have Swahili/SEA versions as well: slave trade.
or J-m172?
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Apollo

Staff Member
so is T considered cushitic or semetic and why?

Cushitic and Semitic are only ~ 6,000-year-old language families.. dude, these haplogroups you mentioned are over 30,000 years old, way before any language group. They are found in many different language groups.

By the way, the true Semitic haplogroup is E-M123. They spread the first Afro-Asiatic dialect from Egypt into the Levant. J1 became Semitic later on by joining the E-M123 tribe.
 
Cushitic and Semitic are only ~ 6,000-year-old language families.. dude, these haplogroups you mentioned are over 30,000 years old, way before any language group. They are found in many different language groups.

By the way, the true Semitic haplogroup is E-M123. They spread the first Afro-Asiatic dialect from Egypt into the Levant. J1 become Semitic later on by joining the E-M123 tribe.
ok good information but haplogroup t originated in the middle east so wouldnt that mean your ancestors are semetic and not cushitic?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top