Did you know that there are two types wills that Allah has when it comes to fate?
Alot of people have this issue which they can't comprehend when it comes to qadr
There is irada shariah and irada qadriyah
Meaning 'will from the point of the shariah and will from the point of qadr
To demonstrat. Here is a story
A man came to the leader of mutaziltes of his time. Mu'tazilahs are muslims who don't believe in qadr and fate and that Allah has decreed things
This guy comes to the leader and says 'my donkey has been stolen. So please make dua to Allah that he returns him back to me'
SO this leader raises his hands and says' Oh Allah you did not want this man's donkey to be stolen so please return it to him'
The man who has no clue about religion immediately goes, listen shiekh stop making dua for me. I dont want it anymore.
So the leader goes why?
The man replies: Listen If Allah didnt want my donkey to be stolen and yet it got stolen then what if Allah wants the donkey to return and yet it does not come back. I fear that. So keep the dua to yourself
And there lies in the issue
Allah never wants the man to lose his donkey or wants it to be stolen. That's irada shariah or will according to intention. Allah wants good.
But there is also irada qadriyah and that is Allah has decreed and allowed the donkey to be stolen. Two different things
Alot of people have this issue which they can't comprehend when it comes to qadr
There is irada shariah and irada qadriyah
Meaning 'will from the point of the shariah and will from the point of qadr
To demonstrat. Here is a story
A man came to the leader of mutaziltes of his time. Mu'tazilahs are muslims who don't believe in qadr and fate and that Allah has decreed things
This guy comes to the leader and says 'my donkey has been stolen. So please make dua to Allah that he returns him back to me'
SO this leader raises his hands and says' Oh Allah you did not want this man's donkey to be stolen so please return it to him'
The man who has no clue about religion immediately goes, listen shiekh stop making dua for me. I dont want it anymore.
So the leader goes why?
The man replies: Listen If Allah didnt want my donkey to be stolen and yet it got stolen then what if Allah wants the donkey to return and yet it does not come back. I fear that. So keep the dua to yourself
And there lies in the issue
Allah never wants the man to lose his donkey or wants it to be stolen. That's irada shariah or will according to intention. Allah wants good.
But there is also irada qadriyah and that is Allah has decreed and allowed the donkey to be stolen. Two different things
