Sharia for Somalia?

Islamic or secular government

  • Secular government

  • Islamic government

  • I'm gaal

Results are only viewable after voting.
AhmedSmelly

AhmedSmelly

I am an offical nacas. too honest
imperialist said:
Agree except the stoning part. The Quran clearly states the punishment for adultery is flogging and doesn't differentiate between the married and unmarried.
Click to expand...

dude start trusting in Allah. Accepting one his rules, and rejecting one is not right.

The thing about stoning an adulterer to death is something of our religion. In the prophets time there was no adulterer who where stoned to death without her coming forward. Most women who were stoned to death at the prophets time which were 4 women I believe. They all wanted to repent for their sin, so they wanted to be stoned to death. They were given a chance to opt out, but they adamantly refused.

Stoning an adulterer to death without their consent is impossible, its a fallacy. The reason for that is explained in a really good way by mufti menk.

 
imperialist

imperialist

AhmedSmelly said:
Hahahahah you are just not knowledgeable enough to understand the hadith. Should I correct you in your mistkake. Or do you want to stay ignorant of the hadith and the prophets sunnah.
Click to expand...
I'm no Scholar and if I'm mistaken may Allah forgive me. I have always had problem reconciling certain hadith's with the Quran. The Quran goes into detail what's allowed for us to eat and the procedures that should be carried out. Even the rules of warfare are described to the letter. What
I don't understand is that Allah would leave out a grave punishment like stoning.
 
GTR

GTR

>islamic government
>qabil

Pick one. I'm personally for being governed by God's divine guidance. Anything to get rid of tribalism really :farole:
 
Ramen

Ramen

🌸
You guys who are voting for sharia would be the first ones to run away if sharia became in the law In your gaal countries :mjlol:
 
AhmedSmelly

AhmedSmelly

I am an offical nacas. too honest
GTR said:
>islamic government
>qabil

Pick one. I'm personally for being governed by God's divine guidance. Anything to get rid of tribalism really :farole:
Click to expand...
there is nothing wrong with tribalism. It worked perfectly for the Quraish. The problem arises with Somalis and their unprecedented Qabil Supremacy. Where they will protect a pedophile just for being in their tribe. Where they wont give their sister her inheritance for being married to a rival tribe. Not wanting their sister to bring the wealth to the rival tribe. Not wanting their niece and nephew to have a headstart in life.

The problem isnt tribalism, the problem lies with Somalis and their digusting practises that goes against Islam. Tribalism is not the problem, it was never the problem.

If the people are evil, dont point the finger on an innocent noun. :hillarybiz:
 
GTR

GTR

AhmedSmelly said:
there is nothing wrong with tribalism. It worked perfectly for the Quraish. The problem arises with Somalis and their unprecedented Qabil Supremacy. Where they will protect a pedophile just for being in their tribe. Where they wont give their sister her inheritance for being married to a rival tribe. Not wanting their sister to bring the wealth to the rival tribe. Not wanting their niece and nephew to have a headstart in life.

The problem isnt tribalism, the problem lies with Somalis and their digusting practises that goes against Islam. Tribalism is not the problem, it was never the problem.

If the people are evil, dont point the finger on an innocent noun. :hillarybiz:
Click to expand...
You completely missed my point sxb. All of those points you've raised are irrelevant. So what if tribalism worked for the Quraish? Wallahi I have never understood the argument of 'tribalism isn't the problem, but somalis are!'

I mean why adhere to a system that is prohibited in the first place? If you look up the definition of the word 'muslim' you will find that it means someone who surrenders and submits to the laws of God. Therefore, a natural consequence (if you're a true muslim) of this is that any action that violates God's command/law in the first place should be immediately stopped or erased.

Say you buy a new phone. You're immediately told by the manufacturer that this particular phone isn't waterproof and asks you to be diligent of this fact. Knowing this, wouldn't it be unwise on your part to take the phone with you to be bathroom? See my point?
 
Last edited:
AhmedSmelly

AhmedSmelly

I am an offical nacas. too honest
GTR said:
You completely missed my point sxb. All of those points you've raised are irrelevant. So what if tribalism worked for the Quraish? Wallahi I have never understood the argument of 'tribalism isn't the problem, but somalis are!'

I mean why adhere to a system that is prohibited in the first place? If you look up the definition of the word 'muslim' you will find that it means someone who surrenders and submits to the laws of God. Therefore, a natural consequence (if you're a true muslim) of this is that any action that violates God's command/law in the first place should be immediately stopped or erased.

Say you buy a new phone. You're immediately told by the manufacturer that this particular phone isn't waterproof and asks you to be diligent of this fact. Knowing this, wouldn't it be unwise on your part to take the phone with you to be bathroom? See my point?
Click to expand...
I cant make you be realistic in life. So lets see what Allah has to say about it:

"O mankind, indeed We have created you from male and female and made you peoples and tribes that you may know one another. Indeed, the most noble of you in the sight of Allah is the most righteous of you. Indeed, Allah is Knowing and Acquainted." Surah al-Hujurat 49:13

Please really evaluate your answer before you give it to me. Allah made us this way, he made us into tribes to differentiate one another. Lets be pragmatic with our thinking.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Trending

Latest posts

Top