Omar del Sur
VIP
He described the earth revolving around the sun as modern theories. While early Muslims knew that the earth and the rest of planet orbit in certain shape, and through the revolving they were able to measure the earth's circumference.
He described the earth revolving around the sun as modern theories. While early Muslims knew that the earth and the rest of planet orbit in certain shape, and through the revolving they were able to measure the earth's circumference.
Did you read this part?the fatwa you linked is talking about whether the earth rotates. it doesn't say anything about whether the sun revolves around the earth. if you believe the sun doesn't revolve around the earth and you say this is the classical view, you are welcome to show which classical scholars were of this view.
this thread is talking about the fact that the sun revolves around the earth. whether the earth is itself stationary or not is a related but separate question. I am not sure whether the earth is stationary.
Did you read this part?
View attachment 320117